tools/binman/README

# SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-2.0+
# Copyright (c) 2016 Google, Inc

Introduction
------------

Firmware often consists of several components which must be packaged together.
For example, we may have SPL, U-Boot, a device tree and an environment area
grouped together and placed in MMC flash. When the system starts, it must be
able to find these pieces.

So far U-Boot has not provided a way to handle creating such images in a
general way. Each SoC does what it needs to build an image, often packing or
concatenating images in the U-Boot build system.

Binman aims to provide a mechanism for building images, from simple
SPL + U-Boot combinations, to more complex arrangements with many parts.


What it does
------------

Binman reads your board's device tree and finds a node which describes the
required image layout. It uses this to work out what to place where. The
output file normally contains the device tree, so it is in principle possible
to read an image and extract its constituent parts.


Features
--------

So far binman is pretty simple. It supports binary blobs, such as 'u-boot',
'spl' and 'fdt'. It supports empty entries (such as setting to 0xff). It can
place entries at a fixed location in the image, or fit them together with
suitable padding and alignment. It provides a way to process binaries before
they are included, by adding a Python plug-in. The device tree is available
to U-Boot at run-time so that the images can be interpreted.

Binman does not yet update the device tree with the final location of
everything when it is done. A simple C structure could be generated for
constrained environments like SPL (using dtoc) but this is also not
implemented.

Binman can also support incorporating filesystems in the image if required.
For example x86 platforms may use CBFS in some cases.

Binman is intended for use with U-Boot but is designed to be general enough
to be useful in other image-packaging situations.


Motivation
----------

Packaging of firmware is quite a different task from building the various
parts. In many cases the various binaries which go into the image come from
separate build systems. For example, ARM Trusted Firmware is used on ARMv8
devices but is not built in the U-Boot tree. If a Linux kernel is included
in the firmware image, it is built elsewhere.

It is of course possible to add more and more build rules to the U-Boot
build system to cover these cases. It can shell out to other Makefiles and
build scripts. But it seems better to create a clear divide between building
software and packaging it.

At present this is handled by manual instructions, different for each board,
on how to create images that will boot. By turning these instructions into a
standard format, we can support making valid images for any board without
manual effort, lots of READMEs, etc.

Benefits:
- Each binary can have its own build system and tool chain without creating
any dependencies between them
- Avoids the need for a single-shot build: individual parts can be updated
and brought in as needed
- Provides for a standard image description available in the build and at
run-time
- SoC-specific image-signing tools can be accomodated
- Avoids cluttering the U-Boot build system with image-building code
- The image description is automatically available at run-time in U-Boot,
SPL. It can be made available to other software also
- The image description is easily readable (it's a text file in device-tree
format) and permits flexible packing of binaries


Terminology
-----------

Binman uses the following terms:

- image - an output file containing a firmware image
- binary - an input binary that goes into the image


Relationship to FIT
-------------------

FIT is U-Boot's official image format. It supports multiple binaries with
load / execution addresses, compression. It also supports verification
through hashing and RSA signatures.

FIT was originally designed to support booting a Linux kernel (with an
optional ramdisk) and device tree chosen from various options in the FIT.
Now that U-Boot supports configuration via device tree, it is possible to
load U-Boot from a FIT, with the device tree chosen by SPL.

Binman considers FIT to be one of the binaries it can place in the image.

Where possible it is best to put as much as possible in the FIT, with binman
used to deal with cases not covered by FIT. Examples include initial
execution (since FIT itself does not have an executable header) and dealing
with device boundaries, such as the read-only/read-write separation in SPI
flash.

For U-Boot, binman should not be used to create ad-hoc images in place of
FIT.


Relationship to mkimage
-----------------------

The mkimage tool provides a means to create a FIT. Traditionally it has
needed an image description file: a device tree, like binman, but in a
different format. More recently it has started to support a '-f auto' mode
which can generate that automatically.

More relevant to binman, mkimage also permits creation of many SoC-specific
image types. These can be listed by running 'mkimage -T list'. Examples
include 'rksd', the Rockchip SD/MMC boot format. The mkimage tool is often
called from the U-Boot build system for this reason.

Binman considers the output files created by mkimage to be binary blobs
which it can place in an image. Binman does not replace the mkimage tool or
this purpose. It would be possible in some situtions to create a new entry
type for the images in mkimage, but this would not add functionality. It
seems better to use the mkiamge tool to generate binaries and avoid blurring
the boundaries between building input files (mkimage) and packaging then
into a final image (binman).


Example use of binman in U-Boot
-------------------------------

Binman aims to replace some of the ad-hoc image creation in the U-Boot
build system.

Consider sunxi. It has the following steps:

1. It uses a custom mksunxiboot tool to build an SPL image called
sunxi-spl.bin. This should probably move into mkimage.

2. It uses mkimage to package U-Boot into a legacy image file (so that it can
hold the load and execution address) called u-boot.img.

3. It builds a final output image called u-boot-sunxi-with-spl.bin which
consists of sunxi-spl.bin, some padding and u-boot.img.

Binman is intended to replace the last step. The U-Boot build system builds
u-boot.bin and sunxi-spl.bin. Binman can then take over creation of
sunxi-spl.bin (by calling mksunxiboot, or hopefully one day mkimage). In any
case, it would then create the image from the component parts.

This simplifies the U-Boot Makefile somewhat, since various pieces of logic
can be replaced by a call to binman.


Example use of binman for x86
-----------------------------

In most cases x86 images have a lot of binary blobs, 'black-box' code
provided by Intel which must be run for the platform to work. Typically
these blobs are not relocatable and must be placed at fixed areas in the
firmare image.

Currently this is handled by ifdtool, which places microcode, FSP, MRC, VGA
BIOS, reference code and Intel ME binaries into a u-boot.rom file.

Binman is intended to replace all of this, with ifdtool left to handle only
the configuration of the Intel-format descriptor.


Running binman
--------------

Type:

	binman -b <board_name>

to build an image for a board. The board name is the same name used when
configuring U-Boot (e.g. for sandbox_defconfig the board name is 'sandbox').
Binman assumes that the input files for the build are in ../b/<board_name>.

Or you can specify this explicitly:

	binman -I <build_path>

where <build_path> is the build directory containing the output of the U-Boot
build.

(Future work will make this more configurable)

In either case, binman picks up the device tree file (u-boot.dtb) and looks
for its instructions in the 'binman' node.

Binman has a few other options which you can see by running 'binman -h'.


Enabling binman for a board
---------------------------

At present binman is invoked from a rule in the main Makefile. Typically you
will have a rule like:

ifneq ($(CONFIG_ARCH_<something>),)
u-boot-<your_suffix>.bin: <input_file_1> <input_file_2> checkbinman FORCE
	$(call if_changed,binman)
endif

This assumes that u-boot-<your_suffix>.bin is a target, and is the final file
that you need to produce. You can make it a target by adding it to ALL-y
either in the main Makefile or in a config.mk file in your arch subdirectory.

Once binman is executed it will pick up its instructions from a device-tree
file, typically <soc>-u-boot.dtsi, where <soc> is your CONFIG_SYS_SOC value.
You can use other, more specific CONFIG options - see 'Automatic .dtsi
inclusion' below.


Image description format
------------------------

The binman node is called 'binman'. An example image description is shown
below:

	binman {
		filename = "u-boot-sunxi-with-spl.bin";
		pad-byte = <0xff>;
		blob {
			filename = "spl/sunxi-spl.bin";
		};
		u-boot {
			pos = <CONFIG_SPL_PAD_TO>;
		};
	};


This requests binman to create an image file called u-boot-sunxi-with-spl.bin
consisting of a specially formatted SPL (spl/sunxi-spl.bin, built by the
normal U-Boot Makefile), some 0xff padding, and a U-Boot legacy image. The
padding comes from the fact that the second binary is placed at
CONFIG_SPL_PAD_TO. If that line were omitted then the U-Boot binary would
immediately follow the SPL binary.

The binman node describes an image. The sub-nodes describe entries in the
image. Each entry represents a region within the overall image. The name of
the entry (blob, u-boot) tells binman what to put there. For 'blob' we must
provide a filename. For 'u-boot', binman knows that this means 'u-boot.bin'.

Entries are normally placed into the image sequentially, one after the other.
The image size is the total size of all entries. As you can see, you can
specify the start position of an entry using the 'pos' property.

Note that due to a device tree requirement, all entries must have a unique
name. If you want to put the same binary in the image multiple times, you can
use any unique name, with the 'type' property providing the type.

The attributes supported for entries are described below.

pos:
	This sets the position of an entry within the image. The first byte
	of the image is normally at position 0. If 'pos' is not provided,
	binman sets it to the end of the previous region, or the start of
	the image's entry area (normally 0) if there is no previous region.

align:
	This sets the alignment of the entry. The entry position is adjusted
	so that the entry starts on an aligned boundary within the image. For
	example 'align = <16>' means that the entry will start on a 16-byte
	boundary. Alignment shold be a power of 2. If 'align' is not
	provided, no alignment is performed.

size:
	This sets the size of the entry. The contents will be padded out to
	this size. If this is not provided, it will be set to the size of the
	contents.

pad-before:
	Padding before the contents of the entry. Normally this is 0, meaning
	that the contents start at the beginning of the entry. This can be
	offset the entry contents a little. Defaults to 0.

pad-after:
	Padding after the contents of the entry. Normally this is 0, meaning
	that the entry ends at the last byte of content (unless adjusted by
	other properties). This allows room to be created in the image for
	this entry to expand later. Defaults to 0.

align-size:
	This sets the alignment of the entry size. For example, to ensure
	that the size of an entry is a multiple of 64 bytes, set this to 64.
	If 'align-size' is not provided, no alignment is performed.

align-end:
	This sets the alignment of the end of an entry. Some entries require
	that they end on an alignment boundary, regardless of where they
	start. If 'align-end' is not provided, no alignment is performed.

	Note: This is not yet implemented in binman.

filename:
	For 'blob' types this provides the filename containing the binary to
	put into the entry. If binman knows about the entry type (like
	u-boot-bin), then there is no need to specify this.

type:
	Sets the type of an entry. This defaults to the entry name, but it is
	possible to use any name, and then add (for example) 'type = "u-boot"'
	to specify the type.

pos-unset:
	Indicates that the position of this entry should not be set by placing
	it immediately after the entry before. Instead, is set by another
	entry which knows where this entry should go. When this boolean
	property is present, binman will give an error if another entry does
	not set the position (with the GetPositions() method).


The attributes supported for images are described below. Several are similar
to those for entries.

size:
	Sets the image size in bytes, for example 'size = <0x100000>' for a
	1MB image.

align-size:
	This sets the alignment of the image size. For example, to ensure
	that the image ends on a 512-byte boundary, use 'align-size = <512>'.
	If 'align-size' is not provided, no alignment is performed.

pad-before:
	This sets the padding before the image entries. The first entry will
	be positionad after the padding. This defaults to 0.

pad-after:
	This sets the padding after the image entries. The padding will be
	placed after the last entry. This defaults to 0.

pad-byte:
	This specifies the pad byte to use when padding in the image. It
	defaults to 0. To use 0xff, you would add 'pad-byte = <0xff>'.

filename:
	This specifies the image filename. It defaults to 'image.bin'.

sort-by-pos:
	This causes binman to reorder the entries as needed to make sure they
	are in increasing positional order. This can be used when your entry
	order may not match the positional order. A common situation is where
	the 'pos' properties are set by CONFIG options, so their ordering is
	not known a priori.

	This is a boolean property so needs no value. To enable it, add a
	line 'sort-by-pos;' to your description.

multiple-images:
	Normally only a single image is generated. To create more than one
	image, put this property in the binman node. For example, this will
	create image1.bin containing u-boot.bin, and image2.bin containing
	both spl/u-boot-spl.bin and u-boot.bin:

	binman {
		multiple-images;
		image1 {
			u-boot {
			};
		};

		image2 {
			spl {
			};
			u-boot {
			};
		};
	};

end-at-4gb:
	For x86 machines the ROM positions start just before 4GB and extend
	up so that the image finished at the 4GB boundary. This boolean
	option can be enabled to support this. The image size must be
	provided so that binman knows when the image should start. For an
	8MB ROM, the position of the first entry would be 0xfff80000 with
	this option, instead of 0 without this option.


Examples of the above options can be found in the tests. See the
tools/binman/test directory.

It is possible to have the same binary appear multiple times in the image,
either by using a unit number suffix (u-boot@0, u-boot@1) or by using a
different name for each and specifying the type with the 'type' attribute.


Sections and hiearchical images
-------------------------------

Sometimes it is convenient to split an image into several pieces, each of which
contains its own set of binaries. An example is a flash device where part of
the image is read-only and part is read-write. We can set up sections for each
of these, and place binaries in them independently. The image is still produced
as a single output file.

This feature provides a way of creating hierarchical images. For example here
is an example image with two copies of U-Boot. One is read-only (ro), intended
to be written only in the factory. Another is read-write (rw), so that it can be
upgraded in the field. The sizes are fixed so that the ro/rw boundary is known
and can be programmed:

	binman {
		section@0 {
			read-only;
			size = <0x100000>;
			u-boot {
			};
		};
		section@1 {
			size = <0x100000>;
			u-boot {
			};
		};
	};

This image could be placed into a SPI flash chip, with the protection boundary
set at 1MB.

A few special properties are provided for sections:

read-only:
	Indicates that this section is read-only. This has no impact on binman's
	operation, but his property can be read at run time.


Special properties
------------------

Some entries support special properties, documented here:

u-boot-with-ucode-ptr:
	optional-ucode: boolean property to make microcode optional. If the
		u-boot.bin image does not include microcode, no error will
		be generated.


Order of image creation
-----------------------

Image creation proceeds in the following order, for each entry in the image.

1. GetEntryContents() - the contents of each entry are obtained, normally by
reading from a file. This calls the Entry.ObtainContents() to read the
contents. The default version of Entry.ObtainContents() calls
Entry.GetDefaultFilename() and then reads that file. So a common mechanism
to select a file to read is to override that function in the subclass. The
functions must return True when they have read the contents. Binman will
retry calling the functions a few times if False is returned, allowing
dependencies between the contents of different entries.

2. GetEntryPositions() - calls Entry.GetPositions() for each entry. This can
return a dict containing entries that need updating. The key should be the
entry name and the value is a tuple (pos, size). This allows an entry to
provide the position and size for other entries. The default implementation
of GetEntryPositions() returns {}.

3. PackEntries() - calls Entry.Pack() which figures out the position and
size of an entry. The 'current' image position is passed in, and the function
returns the position immediately after the entry being packed. The default
implementation of Pack() is usually sufficient.

4. CheckSize() - checks that the contents of all the entries fits within
the image size. If the image does not have a defined size, the size is set
large enough to hold all the entries.

5. CheckEntries() - checks that the entries do not overlap, nor extend
outside the image.

6. ProcessEntryContents() - this calls Entry.ProcessContents() on each entry.
The default implementatoin does nothing. This can be overriden to adjust the
contents of an entry in some way. For example, it would be possible to create
an entry containing a hash of the contents of some other entries. At this
stage the position and size of entries should not be adjusted.

6. WriteEntryInfo()

7. BuildImage() - builds the image and writes it to a file. This is the final
step.


Automatic .dtsi inclusion
-------------------------

It is sometimes inconvenient to add a 'binman' node to the .dts file for each
board. This can be done by using #include to bring in a common file. Another
approach supported by the U-Boot build system is to automatically include
a common header. You can then put the binman node (and anything else that is
specific to U-Boot, such as u-boot,dm-pre-reloc properies) in that header
file.

Binman will search for the following files in arch/<arch>/dts:

   <dts>-u-boot.dtsi where <dts> is the base name of the .dts file
   <CONFIG_SYS_SOC>-u-boot.dtsi
   <CONFIG_SYS_CPU>-u-boot.dtsi
   <CONFIG_SYS_VENDOR>-u-boot.dtsi
   u-boot.dtsi

U-Boot will only use the first one that it finds. If you need to include a
more general file you can do that from the more specific file using #include.
If you are having trouble figuring out what is going on, you can uncomment
the 'warning' line in scripts/Makefile.lib to see what it has found:

   # Uncomment for debugging
   # This shows all the files that were considered and the one that we chose.
   # u_boot_dtsi_options_debug = $(u_boot_dtsi_options_raw)


Access to binman entry positions at run time
--------------------------------------------

Binman assembles images and determines where each entry is placed in the image.
This information may be useful to U-Boot at run time. For example, in SPL it
is useful to be able to find the location of U-Boot so that it can be executed
when SPL is finished.

Binman allows you to declare symbols in the SPL image which are filled in
with their correct values during the build. For example:

    binman_sym_declare(ulong, u_boot_any, pos);

declares a ulong value which will be assigned to the position of any U-Boot
image (u-boot.bin, u-boot.img, u-boot-nodtb.bin) that is present in the image.
You can access this value with something like:

    ulong u_boot_pos = binman_sym(ulong, u_boot_any, pos);

Thus u_boot_pos will be set to the position of U-Boot in memory, assuming that
the whole image has been loaded, or is available in flash. You can then jump to
that address to start U-Boot.

At present this feature is only supported in SPL. In principle it is possible
to fill in such symbols in U-Boot proper, as well.


Code coverage
-------------

Binman is a critical tool and is designed to be very testable. Entry
implementations target 100% test coverage. Run 'binman -T' to check this.

To enable Python test coverage on Debian-type distributions (e.g. Ubuntu):

   $ sudo apt-get install python-pip python-pytest
   $ sudo pip install coverage


Advanced Features / Technical docs
----------------------------------

The behaviour of entries is defined by the Entry class. All other entries are
a subclass of this. An important subclass is Entry_blob which takes binary
data from a file and places it in the entry. In fact most entry types are
subclasses of Entry_blob.

Each entry type is a separate file in the tools/binman/etype directory. Each
file contains a class called Entry_<type> where <type> is the entry type.
New entry types can be supported by adding new files in that directory.
These will automatically be detected by binman when needed.

Entry properties are documented in entry.py. The entry subclasses are free
to change the values of properties to support special behaviour. For example,
when Entry_blob loads a file, it sets content_size to the size of the file.
Entry classes can adjust other entries. For example, an entry that knows
where other entries should be positioned can set up those entries' positions
so they don't need to be set in the binman decription. It can also adjust
entry contents.

Most of the time such essoteric behaviour is not needed, but it can be
essential for complex images.

If you need to specify a particular device-tree compiler to use, you can define
the DTC environment variable. This can be useful when the system dtc is too
old.


History / Credits
-----------------

Binman takes a lot of inspiration from a Chrome OS tool called
'cros_bundle_firmware', which I wrote some years ago. That tool was based on
a reasonably simple and sound design but has expanded greatly over the
years. In particular its handling of x86 images is convoluted.

Quite a few lessons have been learned which are hopefully applied here.


Design notes
------------

On the face of it, a tool to create firmware images should be fairly simple:
just find all the input binaries and place them at the right place in the
image. The difficulty comes from the wide variety of input types (simple
flat binaries containing code, packaged data with various headers), packing
requirments (alignment, spacing, device boundaries) and other required
features such as hierarchical images.

The design challenge is to make it easy to create simple images, while
allowing the more complex cases to be supported. For example, for most
images we don't much care exactly where each binary ends up, so we should
not have to specify that unnecessarily.

New entry types should aim to provide simple usage where possible. If new
core features are needed, they can be added in the Entry base class.


To do
-----

Some ideas:
- Fill out the device tree to include the final position and size of each
  entry (since the input file may not always specify these). See also
  'Access to binman entry positions at run time' above
- Use of-platdata to make the information available to code that is unable
  to use device tree (such as a very small SPL image)
- Write an image map to a text file
- Allow easy building of images by specifying just the board name
- Produce a full Python binding for libfdt (for upstream)
- Add an option to decode an image into the constituent binaries
- Support building an image for a board (-b) more completely, with a
  configurable build directory
- Consider making binman work with buildman, although if it is used in the
  Makefile, this will be automatic
- Implement align-end

--
Simon Glass <sjg@chromium.org>
7/7/2016