BUG/MEDIUM: ocsp: Separate refcount per instance and per store
With the current way OCSP responses are stored, a single OCSP response
is stored (in a certificate_ocsp structure) when it is loaded during a
certificate parsing, and each ckch_inst that references it increments
its refcount. The reference to the certificate_ocsp is actually kept in
the SSL_CTX linked to each ckch_inst, in an ex_data entry that gets
freed when he context is freed.
One of the downside of this implementation is that is every ckch_inst
referencing a certificate_ocsp gets detroyed, then the OCSP response is
removed from the system. So if we were to remove all crt-list lines
containing a given certificate (that has an OCSP response), the response
would be destroyed even if the certificate remains in the system (as an
unused certificate). In such a case, we would want the OCSP response not
to be "usable", since it is not used by any ckch_inst, but still remain
in the OCSP response tree so that if the certificate gets reused (via an
"add ssl crt-list" command for instance), its OCSP response is still
known as well. But we would also like such an entry not to be updated
automatically anymore once no instance uses it. An easy way to do it
could have been to keep a reference to the certificate_ocsp structure in
the ckch_store as well, on top of all the ones in the ckch_instances,
and to remove the ocsp response from the update tree once the refcount
falls to 1, but it would not work because of the way the ocsp response
tree keys are calculated. They are decorrelated from the ckch_store and
are the actual OCSP_CERTIDs, which is a combination of the issuer's name
hash and key hash, and the certificate's serial number. So two copies of
the same certificate but with different names would still point to the
same ocsp response tree entry.
The solution that answers to all the needs expressed aboved is actually
to have two reference counters in the certificate_ocsp structure, one
for the actual ckch instances and one for the ckch stores. If the
instance refcount becomes 0 then we remove the entry from the auto
update tree, and if the store reference becomes 0 we can then remove the
OCSP response from the tree. This would allow to chain some "del ssl
crt-list" and "add ssl crt-list" CLI commands without losing any
functionality.
Must be backported to 2.8.
(cherry picked from commit befebf8b5123a1dd88d7d11298d63356f15d87b8)
Signed-off-by: Christopher Faulet <cfaulet@haproxy.com>
(cherry picked from commit 04b77f84d1b52185fc64735d7d81137479d68b00)
Signed-off-by: Willy Tarreau <w@1wt.eu>
5 files changed