OPTIM: epoll: always poll for recv if neither active nor ready
The cost of enabling polling in one direction with epoll is very high
because it requires one syscall per FD and per direction change. In
addition we don't know about input readiness until we either try to
receive() or enable polling and watch the result. With HTTP keep-alive,
both are equally expensive as it's very uncommon to see the server
instantly respond (unless it's a second stage of the same process on
localhost, which has become much less common with threads).
But when a connection is established it's also quite usual to have to
poll for sending (except on localhost or UNIX sockets where it almost
always instantly works). So this cost of polling could be factored out
with the second step if both were enabled together.
This is the idea behind this patch. What it does is to always enable
polling for Rx if it's not ready and at least one direction is active.
This means that if it's not explicitly disabled, or if it was but in a
state that causes the loss of the information (rx ready cannot be
guessed), then let's take any opportunity for a polling change to
enable it at the same time, and learn about rx readiness for free.
In addition the FD never gets unregistered for Rx unless it's ready
and was blocked (buffer full). This avoids a lot of the flip-flop
behaviour at beginning and end of requests.
On a test with 10k requests in keep-alive, the difference is quite
noticeable:
Before:
% time seconds usecs/call calls errors syscall
------ ----------- ----------- --------- --------- ----------------
83.67 0.010847 0 20078 epoll_ctl
16.33 0.002117 0 2231 epoll_wait
0.00 0.000000 0 20 20 connect
------ ----------- ----------- --------- --------- ----------------
100.00 0.012964 22329 20 total
After:
% time seconds usecs/call calls errors syscall
------ ----------- ----------- --------- --------- ----------------
96.35 0.003351 1 2644 epoll_wait
2.36 0.000082 4 20 20 connect
1.29 0.000045 0 66 epoll_ctl
------ ----------- ----------- --------- --------- ----------------
100.00 0.003478 2730 20 total
It may also save a recvfrom() after connect() by changing the following
sequence, effectively saving one epoll_ctl() and one recvfrom() :
before | after
-----------------------------+----------------------------
- connect() | - connect()
- epoll_ctl(add,out) | - epoll_ctl(add, in|out)
- sendto() | - epoll_wait() = out
- epoll_ctl(mod,in|out) | - send()
- epoll_wait() = out | - epoll_wait() = in|out
- recvfrom() = EAGAIN | - recvfrom() = OK
- epoll_ctl(mod,in) | - recvfrom() = EAGAIN
- epoll_wait() = in | - epoll_ctl(mod, in)
- recvfrom() = OK | - epoll_wait()
- recvfrom() = EAGAIN |
- epoll_wait() |
(...)
Now on a 10M req test on 16 threads with 2k concurrent conns and 415kreq/s,
we see 190k updates total and 14k epoll_ctl() only.
1 file changed