tree 15b72dc3f060747ba38199ec9213f700955f8e40
parent ba6ac52675b2f9c563d30f5d3528ccf1e0fecda5
author Jimmy Brisson <jimmy.brisson@arm.com> 1611178491 -0600
committer Jimmy Brisson <jimmy.brisson@arm.com> 1611758563 +0000

cert-tool: avoid duplicates in extension stack

This bug manifests itself as a segfault triggered by a double-free.

I noticed that right before the double-free, the sk list contained 2
elements with the same address.

    (gdb) p sk_X509_EXTENSION_value(sk, 1)
    $34 = (X509_EXTENSION *) 0x431ad0
    (gdb) p sk_X509_EXTENSION_value(sk, 0)
    $35 = (X509_EXTENSION *) 0x431ad0
    (gdb) p sk_X509_EXTENSION_num(sk)
    $36 = 2

This caused confusion; this should never happen.

I figured that this was caused by a ext_new_xxxx function freeing
something before it is added to the list, so I put a breakpoint on
each of them to step through. I was suprised to find that none of my
breakpoints triggered for the second element of the iteration through
the outer loop just before the double-free.

Looking through the code, I noticed that it's possible to avoid doing
a ext_new_xxxx, when either:
   * ext->type == NVCOUNTER and ext->arg == NULL
   * ext->type == HASH and ext->arg == NULL and ext->optional == false
So I put a breakpoint on both.

It turns out that it was the HASH version, but I added a fix for both.
The fix for the Hash case is simple, as it was a mistake. The fix for
the NVCOUNTER case, however, is a bit more subtle. The NVCOUNTER may
be optional, and when it's optional we can skip it. The other case,
when the NVCOUNTER is required (not optinal), the `check_cmd_params`
function has already verified that the `ext->arg` must be non-NULL.
We assert that before processing it to covert any possible segfaults
into more descriptive errors.

This should no longer cause double-frees by adding the same ext twice.

Change-Id: Idae2a24ecd964b0a3929e6193c7f85ec769f6470
Signed-off-by: Jimmy Brisson <jimmy.brisson@arm.com>